Moody\'s Investors Service said that the Russian government\'s support measures for the Russian banking sector are unlikely to lead to any upgrades as both liquidity and capital will be allocated mainly to state banks with ratings that already incorporate a very high degree of systemic support. Moreover, the recent measures are understood to be temporary support for the banking system and therefore will not affect Moody\'s long-term ratings.
Similarly, the measures are unlikely to prevent downgrades of banks that have relative weaknesses in their business model that are not necessarily due to temporary funding shortages. In fact, the financial crisis may reveal fundamental weaknesses in a bank\'s asset quality, capital or business model.
For a discussion of Moody\'s approach towards government support for banking systems, see Moody\'s Special Comment \"Assessing the Rating Implications for Banks of the Current Market Turmoil and Governmental Interventions to Support Their Banking Systems\" which was published on 8 October 2008.
The Russian government\'s announced support measures include:
- Plans to provide RUB950 billion (USD36.3 billion) in the form of ten-year subordinated loans to eligible institutions (see below for details);
- An increase in the amount of federal budget funds eligible for placement with commercial banks to RUB1.5 trillion (USD57.3 billion) and proposed extension of the list of banks entitled to hold these funds to more than 100, up from 28 as of today;
- Proposals to allow the Central Bank of Russia (CBR) to provide loans to commercial banks on a non-collateralised basis;
- Access for all banks to direct repo deals with the CBR (previously only available to banks classified as \"financially stable\" by the CBR);
- Increase in the amount of private deposits subject to 100% compensation under the Deposit Insurance Scheme to RUB700,00 (USD26,750) from RUB100,000 (USD3,800); and
- The allocation of USD50 billion from CBR\'s foreign currency reserves to the state-owned Vnesheconombank (in the form of CBR\'s deposit) for onlending to banks and companies with external debt obligations that are falling due soon.
Eligible institutions are mainly state-owned banks that have a systemic importance for the Russian banking sector. Sberbank, the country\'s largest bank (rated D+/A1) is expected to receive more than half of the total allocated funds -- RUB500 billion (USD19.1 billion) -- directly from CBR, its controlling shareholder. The remaining RUB450 billion (USD17.2 billion) will be channelled into the banking system through Vnesheconombank, which will provide RUB200 billion (USD7.6 billion) to the majority state-owned Bank VTB, Russia\'s second-largest bank (rated D-/A1). Vnesheconombank will also provide RUB25 billion (USD0.9 billion) to another state bank, Russian Agricultural Bank (rated E+/A3) and RUB225 billion (USD8.6 billion) to private banks. This will be on the condition that their shareholders make contributions in the same form of long-term subordinated loans of an amount equal to 200% of the funds allocated by the government.
The increase in the amount of federal budget funds eligible for placement with commercial banks derives mainly from a significant extension of the limits set on the state banks. The limit on Sberbank has been increased to RUB754 billion (USD29 billion), on Bank VTB to RUB268.5 billion (USD10.3 billion) and on Gazprombank, the country\'s third-largest bank (rated D-/A3) to RUB104 billion (USD4 billion)
Moody\'s generally views these measures as helpful for the following reasons:
- The amount of long-term subordinated loans provided will be equal to 30% of the Russian banking sector\'s total equity as of 1 September 2008. This will create a significant buffer for the loan losses that Moody\'s expects to materialise over the next 12--18 months as a result of the liquidity squeeze and the slowdown of economic growth. It is likely, that in the event of material asset quality deterioration subordinated loans provided to state-owned banks will be converted into Tier 1 capital. These funds will significantly increase the ability of banks (mainly state-owned but possibly some private ones as well) to lend money and mitigate the negative effects of the liquidity squeeze and weaker economic growth.
- Moody\'s expects that the liquidity and capital support provided by the Russian government will ease some of the more extreme pressure being exerted on the banks by the market. In Moody\'s opinion, this pressure is not fully related to the fundamentals of the banks themselves. In particular, the allocation of funds to companies facing repayments of their cross-border obligations could reduce the direct and indirect negative impact on the banking system from possible defaults of some Russian banks and companies on their external debt.
However, Moody\'s also believes that there is a risk that the pool of liquidity provided by the government will not be fully distributed by the state-owned banks to private banks, particularly small and medium-sized ones, as it is presently unclear what incentives and risk mitigation mechanisms state banks have to be involved in such interbank lending. If the state banks fail to fully distribute the liquidity, the amount of government support might be insufficient to deal with the current liquidity crisis in the banking market.
For a detailed description of the possible impact of the current credit and liquidity crisis on Russian banks please refer to Moody\'s Banking System Outlook on Russia published in September 2008. |